Close
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 15
  1. #1
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Posts
    263
    Thanks Given
    160
    Thanked 322 Times in 114 Posts

    Article: Affordable Radar Detector Testing - 3/15/2015


  2. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to Vortex For This Useful Post:

    winterbrew (06-02-2015), Yellowcab (05-29-2015)

  3. #2
    Senior Member RedRocket's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    North America
    Posts
    2,057
    Thanks Given
    1,081
    Thanked 1,543 Times in 846 Posts
    *First off, I want to express/say to both Vortex & joehemi my gratitude & Thank You's for performing AND sharing the results here, plus props to those who sent the loner RDs !

    34.7 Results:
    (Quote)-"Ok now, here's where things start to get a little weird.Almost every detector performed...w/ the battery handle leaning against the A-pillar to the left of the steering wheel dash hump." -

    As you stated all RDs seemed to not do well & I believe this to possibly be a clue as to what was going on. It would appear to me that the radar source could very well be contributing to the issue you were experiencing, however not due to the orientation as you correctly indicate, but rather the positioning location is what I'm suggesting. I'll speculate further you introduced phase perturbations throughout the wavefront of the emitted signal caused by the sharp curvature of the W/S at this location acting as a weird size medium of varying thickness as a transmit Shaping Lens. It's not just the curve itself but also the transit-time propagation delay thru more "thicker" portions of glass where the curvature becomes much sharper in close proximity to meet the A-pillar.

    Maybe next time you could have "joehemi" just lay the Stalker II on its side (gangsta style) on top of the dash hump for comparison to see what happens.
    Last edited by RedRocket; 05-31-2015 at 06:36 AM.

  4. #3
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Posts
    263
    Thanks Given
    160
    Thanked 322 Times in 114 Posts
    This is interesting considering I didn't create this thread. Is someone posting under my name?

    Is this an automated posting created when an article is posted with me as the contributing author?

    Edit: Ohhhh, nevermind. This is a comment thread for an article. Got it.

  5. #4
    Senior Member BestRadarDetectors's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2013
    Location
    NJ
    Posts
    4,503
    Thanks Given
    472
    Thanked 5,550 Times in 2,134 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Vortex View Post
    This is interesting considering I didn't create this thread. Is someone posting under my name?

    Is this an automated posting created when an article is posted with me as the contributing author?

    Edit: Ohhhh, nevermind. This is a comment thread for an article. Got it.
    Your original post was just promoted to an Article so readers can find it on the main page if they did not want to search the forums.
    Need Help Choosing a Radar Detector for your needs? Visit our website: http://www.bestradardetectors.net, Send us a PM or call us at 1-888-229-7594
    Before looking at an Escort Radar Detector you should really check out Uniden Detectors.. Uniden R1 & R3 are the best performing radar detectors for the money.

  6. #5
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Posts
    263
    Thanks Given
    160
    Thanked 322 Times in 114 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by RedRocket View Post
    It would appear to me that the radar source could very well be contributing to the issue you were experiencing, however not due to the orientation as you correctly indicate, but rather the positioning location is what I'm suggesting.
    I just asked joehemi after reading your question and he said that all the Ka antennas were mounted in the exact same location. Trying to keep things apples to apples as much as possible as always. The only exception was the K band antenna where the antenna cable was really short so it was placed in the center of the dash.

    Speaking of followups, BRD just sent me a few more Unidens to see if we can find a new possible contender for the best pick for the affordable radar detector.

    Quote Originally Posted by BestRadarDetectors View Post
    Your original post was just promoted to an Article so readers can find it on the main page if they did not want to search the forums.
    Thank you for clarifying, and for the article/post promotion!

  7. #6
    Senior Member RedRocket's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    North America
    Posts
    2,057
    Thanks Given
    1,081
    Thanked 1,543 Times in 846 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Vortex View Post
    I just asked joehemi after reading your question and he said that all the Ka antennas were mounted in the exact same location. Trying to keep things apples to apples as much as possible as always. The only exception was the K band antenna where the antenna cable was really short so it was placed in the center of the dash.

    Speaking of followups, BRD just sent me a few more Unidens to see if we can find a new possible contender for the best pick for the affordable radar detector. - hahaha, no rest for the weary ! If the Testing hole you're in keeps getting deeper, maybe it's time to stop digging, .



    Thank you for clarifying, and for the article/post promotion! - a deserved upgrade, you guys earned it for that Review.
    I'm glad to hear what "joehemi" said about the Gun locations, b/c that prompted me today to take my Stalker II MDR out (in the rain I should add) & try to see what I got thru W/S center & next to A-pillar. My ride doesn't have as sharp a curve as his. I found no diff. between the 2 locations on a narrow corridor (sans the curves & hills you guys had) of ~5,000ft. Max range w/ no rain was around 4300-4500ft from both W/S locations & same outside of Driver window. That surprised me a little b/c I expected some loss thru the W/S.
    Light to med-light rain caused a reduction of range of ~400-500ft.

    Same effects on my FalconHR, but ~600-800ft loss of range in the rain...I expected more.
    Max range w/ no rain is ~ 3800ft for K-band.

    Range distances above were obtained w/ Lidar gun.


    p.s. - It now appears that the 34.7 range issues you experience could be humidity related possibly. Do you know what it was that day ?
    Last edited by RedRocket; 05-31-2015 at 10:22 PM.

  8. #7
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Posts
    263
    Thanks Given
    160
    Thanked 322 Times in 114 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by RedRocket View Post
    hahaha, no rest for the weary ! If the Testing hole you're in keeps getting deeper, maybe it's time to stop digging,
    What more could I possibly ask for than a life spent doing what I love?

    Quote Originally Posted by RedRocket View Post
    I'm glad to hear what "joehemi" said about the Gun locations, b/c that prompted me today to take my Stalker II MDR out (in the rain I should add) & try to see what I got thru W/S center & next to A-pillar. My ride doesn't have as sharp a curve as his. I found no diff. between the 2 locations on a narrow corridor (sans the curves & hills you guys had) of ~5,000ft. Max range w/ no rain was around 4300-4500ft from both W/S locations & same outside of Driver window. That surprised me a little b/c I expected some loss thru the W/S.
    Light to med-light rain caused a reduction of range of ~400-500ft.

    Same effects on my FalconHR, but ~600-800ft loss of range in the rain...I expected more.
    Max range w/ no rain is ~ 3800ft for K-band.

    Range distances above were obtained w/ Lidar gun.

    p.s. - It now appears that the 34.7 range issues you experience could be humidity related possibly. Do you know what it was that day ?
    That's interesting about the detection capabilities in the rain. It's great to see that your tests showed the RD's to still be capable in the rain.

    I don't know the exact humidity levels on that day of testing, but I can tell you that it was rainy all day.

    For the sake of consistency I prefer having no rain, but given that this is the PNW and rain is a pretty common occurrence here (and that they run radar in the rain too), I find it invaluable to test in the rain and see how my detectors fare. It doesn't make for the best uncontrolled-variable-free test ever though. It'd be cool to do the exact same test in the rain and dry to see the difference, but I have found recently that a small movement in the antenna's orientation can have a noticeable impact on the detector's detection capabilities, so trying to come back a different day and recreate the test doesn't totally satisfy the perfectionist in me, but it can be very telling nonetheless.

  9. The Following User Says Thank You to Vortex For This Useful Post:

    Yellowcab (06-01-2015)

  10. #8
    Senior Member RedRocket's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    North America
    Posts
    2,057
    Thanks Given
    1,081
    Thanked 1,543 Times in 846 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Vortex View Post
    What more could I possibly ask for than a life spent doing what I love?- Amen to that !



    That's interesting about the detection capabilities in the rain. It's great to see that your tests showed the RD's to still be capable in the rain.

    I don't know the exact humidity levels on that day of testing, but I can tell you that it was rainy all day.
    The humidity level is only part way down the path of where we should go trying to resolve the issue you had w/ 34.7GHz. Obviously 34.7 shouldn't be the only Ka frequency selectively subject to humidity level, but 33.8 & 35.5 should have indicated similar results but didn't. K-band range is far more impacted by humidity than Ka. Conditions for me yesterday were from extremely dry & transitioned to ~70-75 % humidity when the storm moved in mid-Morning. I would guess your humidity level there was 90 % plus.
    Can I assume you & joehemi were using full power (~25mw) 33.8 & 35.5 dash Models & not handguns ? I'm now beginning to wonder about the Stalker's output level. Were you using a +12v power cable feed to the gun handle or running on battery handle only ? If the Stalker had low output power this might explain what occurred. Instead of spending $$$ to have it Certified at a Calibration shop, how 'bout doing a max range check yourself on a remote rural road where you can catch a single vehicle coming at you at a time from 4k to 5k feet in distance.

    When I did mine yesterday I had "Mode" set to ("FCLO") for approaching vehicles only as I guessed that's how you 2 were operating. Of course, larger vehicles (P/U & trucks) return more signal at greater distance than compact cars. This would be a cheap way to see if your Stalker is operating normally & has the same range results as mine does.

  11. #9
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Posts
    263
    Thanks Given
    160
    Thanked 322 Times in 114 Posts
    I think you're starting to overcomplicate things...

    All the guns were standard guns. Bee III, Stalker II, and Golden Eagle for Ka. I don't remember which gun we used for K band, but it was also a standard gun. No trickery with Falcon HR's or anything.

    The Stalker II is working fine, the calibration was good up to about a year ago, and we used a fully charged battery.

    To add more data points and give us a better idea of the big picture, particularly without rain being a factor, here's a more recent test along similar lines. In that one we used a Bee III, Stalker II, Genesis II, and Python II. (Funny how they all have a II or III at the end of their name.) Anyways, in this one, overall from best to worst it was K band, 33.8, 34.7, 35.5.

    Is it because of something inherent to the radar guns? Quite possibly. Are detectors more sensitive to some bands than others? That can be a factor too. Are there other factors involved that we may not be considering? That's a definite possibility as well.

    This is why I like doing many, many tests. Things can happen in one test to make your results sometimes seem a bit wonky, sometimes a detector will have a freakishly good or bad detection, sometimes traffic will come in at just the right/wrong time to give you better or worse range than you normally would, etc.

    I like looking at multiple tests to get a feel for the big picture and weed out any outliers within a single test. This test is one of many to consider when looking to understand how these tools work.

  12. #10
    Senior Member RedRocket's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    North America
    Posts
    2,057
    Thanks Given
    1,081
    Thanked 1,543 Times in 846 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Vortex View Post
    I think you're starting to overcomplicate things...

    All the guns were standard guns. Bee III, Stalker II, and Golden Eagle for Ka. I don't remember which gun we used for K band, but it was also a standard gun. No trickery with Falcon HR's or anything.

    The Stalker II is working fine, the calibration was good up to about a year ago, and we used a fully charged battery.

    To add more data points and give us a better idea of the big picture, particularly without rain being a factor, here's a more recent test along similar lines. In that one we used a Bee III, Stalker II, Genesis II, and Python II. (Funny how they all have a II or III at the end of their name.) Anyways, in this one, overall from best to worst it was K band, 33.8, 34.7, 35.5.
    I'm not interested in using your Hot Link to that Forum as I'm on an extended leave of absence from there until they get serious about moving forward from the past.(Comments from Staff to my departure Post lacked a far from conciliatory tone or attitude as I suspected would happen!!! - so please refrain from repeating that.)

    I wasn't attempting to complicate the inquiry, but rather pointing out the transmitted power level difference factors between the various models which could affect range.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •